Hoda Muthana — and the government that doesn’t want her back. The Trump administration on Wednesday declared that the Alabama woman — who joined ISIS in Syria four usa citizen brides ago but is now begging to be allowed back home — is not a US citizen and will not be allowed to return. But her family’s lawyer insists she is an American — and that he has proof. The State Department did not explain its basis for declaring that Muthana isn’t a citizen, but attorney Hassan Shibly says the feds claim her father was a diplomat at the time of her birth — and the babies of diplomats don’t get citizenship like other tots born in the US do.
Shibly, however, claims her dad had ceased working as a diplomat months before she was born in Hackensack, New Jersey on Oct. 28, 1994 — sharing as evidence a photo of her birth certificate, and one of a letter from the United States Mission to the U. 14, 2004, stating that her dad, Ahemed Ali Muthana, was a diplomat for Yemen from Oct. Another lawyer representing Muthana’s family told the New York Times her dad provided a letter to officials when her first American passport was issued as a child, showing that he had been discharged as a diplomat. Muthana then successfully renewed her passport before running off to join ISIS in late 2014, Charlie Swift, the director of the Constitutional Law Center for Muslims in America, told the paper. Her dad then sent back evidence of his diplomatic discharge, but never received a response, the attorney told the Times. Legal eagles say the government may be able to mount a case against her claim to citizenship — but it’s far from as cut and dry as Trump and Pompeo made it sound.
It is completely possible that there is a factual and legal dispute to be resolved here. Stephen Vladeck, a professor at the University of Texas School of Law who specializes in constitutional and national security law. If she applies for passport and is rejected, she’s entitled to challenge that. If the government claims she’s not a citizen, she’s entitled to challenge that. No matter what the right answer, it’s supposed to come at the end of a process that’s not clear to me has taken place at all. Because of the power of diplomatic immunity, there’s no gray area or transitional period once someone ceases to be a diplomat, Vladeck said. I think it’s going to be a court that has the last word.
This story has been shared 98,689 times. This story has been shared 94,888 times. This story has been shared 56,367 times. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Globalmatri offers the best matrimonial shaadi services in US Citizen. Permanent Residents-Green Card Holders, H1B visa holders, are all seeking Shaadi thru our excellent services, in US Citizen Matrimonial with an east-west blend of Hindu religion and Indian culture life partner from this State. Thank you for your prompt and courteous reply- I am truly amazed and thankful for the wonderful support you provide for all of us here in the United States with sons and daughters!
I hope you continue your good services and let us hope other children get their wishes fulfilled through this important service. Hindu North Indians, Gujaratis, Punjabis, Sikhs, South Indian Brahmins, South Indian Other Varna and Married, Separated. ISIS bride’s citizenship, while the U. Hoda Muthana, an American woman who joined the Islamic State, told a reporter she would ‘prefer’ to return to the U. Now she has an 18-month-old son and she wants to return to the U. Shamima Begum, meanwhile, ran away from the U. Syria and marry an ISIS fighter herself.
She gave birth to a son last weekend, and now she, too, wants to return to the country from whence she came. Begum’s wish to return there by revoking her citizenship. Home Secretary Sajid Javid had the power to do that thanks to an amendment introduced to the British Nationality Act in 2014. United Kingdom, any of the islands, or any British overseas territory. That amendment also contained a caveat: there must be reasonable grounds for believing that the person can become a national of another country.
Devyani Prabhat, reader in law at the University of Bristol, for The Conversation. Reports have suggested that Begum is a British-Bangladeshi, born in the U. However, Bangladesh has said Begum is not a citizen and won’t accept her in the country, The Guardian reported. Begum’s family plans to challenge the decision, reported BBC News. READ MORE: British teenager who joined Islamic State in Syria to lose U. Leah West, a former national security lawyer with Canada’s Department of Justice, now seeking a doctorate at the University of Toronto’s Faculty of Law. These states are saying these young people were our citizens, they’ve perpetrated crimes against innocent civilians potentially or facilitated crimes against innocent civilians in other countries, now we’re giving them to someone else to deal with.
Hoda Muthana is suing the Trump administration over its denials that she’s an American citizen. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is denying she has any U. The administration has asserted this because it said Muthana’s father was serving as a Yemeni diplomat to the UN when she was born in New Jersey. WATCH: American-born ISIS bride hopes to return to U. The lawsuit argues that Muthana’s father ceased being a diplomat prior to her birth — one month prior, according to a family lawyer who spoke to Rukmini Callimachi of The New York Times. That same lawyer told the Times that Muthana’s father was asked to prove that he had been discharged from his post. Muthana subsequently received two passports from the U.
2014, which she used to travel abroad and join ISIS. University of Texas law professor Steve Vladeck said in a blog post that this doesn’t necessarily mean the U. State Department determined conclusively that Muthana is a citizen. But it is deeply suggestive of the conclusion that Muthana’s father was, as a matter of law, no longer entitled to diplomatic immunity at the time of her birth, and so her birth on U. Vladeck went on to note that U. Citizenship can be revoked in cases where an American has committed treason, but even there, the individual must be convicted first. West noted that the Trump administration has called on other countries to repatriate their people who fought with ISIS — and yet, it won’t take Muthana back.
